Sunday, September 20, 2020


Home Archive Cortina Landfill Lease Terminated by BIA

Cortina Landfill Lease Terminated by BIA

After more than a decade of diligent battle by the Colusa County Board of Supervisors on behalf of the county and its residents it appears the proposed and strongly county-opposed landfill at the Cortina Rancheria has been stopped.

Colusa County outside Counsel Tim Taylor of Stoel Rives, LLP brought the news at the Oct. 22 Board meeting. The Bureau of Indian Affairs (BIA) has recently terminated the lease between Cortina Integrated Waste Management Inc. (CIWMI) and the Cortina Band of Wintun Indians. Initially CIWMI’s, (a subsidiary of Earthworks Industries, a Canadian business) intent was to construct and operate an integrated waste handling facility on 443 acres of the Rancheria in Colusa County. The Class III, municipal waste landfill, would be located approximately 85 miles north-east of San Francisco and would have an approximate disposal capacity of 16 million cubic yards of waste.

The landfill would have encompassed approximately 200 acres of the 443 acres leased and increase from an initial 300 tons per day (TPD) of disposal to 1500 TPD. The initial lease of 25 years, renewable for 25 years, also allowed for future material recovery, composting and bio-remediation.

The U.S Department of the Interior, Bureau of Indian Affairs, issued a final approval of the lease in January 2007.

Termination of the lease puts a stop on the project which has been and continues to be opposed by the County and by residents here – especially the residents on Spring Valley Road, the road which would have been most impacted by the truck traffic from the landfill which would be located at the end of that road.

“The implication of the landfill developing at the end of Spring Valley Road was considerable for the county and for its residents,” said Taylor. “The county became involved later than it should have if the Federal Government had done what it was supposed to do and brought the county in,” said Taylor. – But the county still got involved when early on it addressed the absence of an environmental review under the Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) and really dealt pretty aggressively with the BIA in terms of holding its and other federal agencies’ feet to the fire demanding compliance with federal environmental statutes.

Taylor said the secondary component in all of this is that the California Environmental Quality Act wouldn’t normally apply on tribal land but in this instance it did because the road needed to access the site would need significant improvement because of the associated increase in traffic.

Both national and state environmental review resulted in a number of objections by the CIWMI and the BIA. The county filed a federal lawsuit early on which resulted in a settlement and mediation process. “The county’s eight to nine year process concluded with parties standing down and the landfill project not going forward for a number of reasons,” said Taylor.


Additionally Taylor said the federal government advised there would be a need for additional rounds of permitting from the EPA and BIA before the project could come to fruition. This would mean a much longer road for completion.

When this first began it appeared that it would be a quick and dirty, easy thing to get approved and up in running in a couple of years. But as the process went on and the county continued to fight for the rights of the county several things happened.

Recently a contested issue between Earthworks and North Bay, one of the financial participants who had joined forces to get the project through brought a legal action which resulted in CIWMI/Earthworks owing substantial dollars to North Bay. Taylor said it appears that Earthworks didn’t make good on some payments to North Bay.

That is when BIA stepped in to inform CIWMI/Earthworks that its lease would be terminated for failure to abide by terms. CIWMI/Earthworks missed a payment on a $6 million settlement.

Although the lease has been cancelled, CIWMI/Earthworks has the option to seek higher review with the Interior Board of Indian Appeals (IBIA) appellate review body.

Colusa County appeared at the IBIA years ago and ended up with a settlement after the federal lawsuit. After working toward environmental review, the county entered into an agreement with CIWMI for reimbursement of any and all costs the county expended on its environmental review and analysis including legal fees and consultants.

Supervisors Kim Vann and Mark Marshall have served on a sub-committee with Taylor and Colusa County Counsel Marcos Kropf to address the issues on the Cortina Landfill project.

At the Oct. 22 meeting Marshall moved to authorize outside counsel to intervene, or participate as Amicus Curiae in the appeal by CIWMI of the cancellation of the lease for the proposed landfill site in Colusa County.

“For more than 13 years this has been a personal fight for me not only because the proposed project is in my district, but because of the potential environmental impacts. It would be devastating on groundwater and aquifers providing water to the city of Williams, the town of Arbuckle and a western portion of Colusa County,” said Marshall. “I think I would be remiss if I did not continue the fight. For that reason I would vote to give outside counsel authorization to intervene on behalf of the county.”

Vann seconded the motion with comment. She confirmed with Taylor that if the cancellation of the lease was upheld the project proponent’s only next remedy would be to go to federal court and that the BIA would be represented by the Solicitor General.

The board voted 5-0 to approve the motion.

Lloyd Green Jr, Editor
Lloyd Green Jr, Editor
Lloyd Green Jr. is the Owner and Publisher of the Williams Pioneer Review. He is dedicated in publishing the news and informing the community of Colusa County. Lloyd has been with the publication since 2008, and purchased the business in 2010. Under his ownership the newspaper has grown significantly in subscriptions, publishes weekly, and obtained the title of Newspaper of General Circulation by the Superior Court of Colusa County in Sept. 2017. Lloyd is also the director of advertising, classified manager, legal notice clerk, and circulation manager. To contact Lloyd, email him at or call (530) 458-4141 ext. 100.

More News

Three killed on I-5 in two separate accidents 

Three people were killed on Interstate 5 in Colusa County over a five day period in two separate accidents.  A Yuba City couple were killed...

Garden Club Plant Sale

The Garden Club of Colusa County hosted their fall plant sale in the Davison Pavilion in Colusa on Saturday, Sept. 8. The event, which...

Coaches Corner: Dan Kiely

Soccer in Colusa County has a long history of competitive play and a major contributor to that tradition is Colusa High School boys’ soccer...

First Patriot Day ceremony held at Williams Elementary School

Students who attend Williams Elementary School were not alive 19 years ago when hijackers used airplanes as weapons of destruction to kill nearly 3,000...

Distance learning raises questions about home imagery

Editors Note: The article has been updated from the print version to correct the spelling of Tiffany Sines. Distance learning seems to be more challenging...

Local Government

County appoints new Airport Advisory Committee

The Colusa County Board of Supervisors on Sept. 1 appointed seven members to the newly restructured Airport Advisory Committee. The previous committee of about 15...

Colusa Police Department: July 2020

The City of Colusa Police Department responded to 382 calls for service, up from 311 in June. There were an additional 31 calls to...

City of Colusa adopts strategy for economic development

The Colusa City Council last week adopted the final Comprehensive Economic Development Strategy, a report that will serve as a roadmap intended to diversify...

Public & Legal Notices

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT FILE NO. 2020-0000072 Date filed: September 11, 2020 The following persons are doing business as: GULLATT RANCH Business Address: 6880 GREENBAY ROAD, ARBUCKLE, CA 95912 Mailing...

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT FILE NO. 2020-0000071 Date filed: September 1, 2020 The following persons are doing business as: C & C ENGINEERING Business Address: 2081 LONE STAR ROAD,...

Notice of Lien Sale

NOTICE OF LIEN SALE SEPTEMBER 20, 2020 AT 5:00 PM 423 SIOC STREET, COLUSA, CA 95932 8’  3’ GOLD WING 09/16/2020 • WPR #2020-1142


CIUDAD DE COLUSA AVISO DE AUDIENCIA PÚBLICA AVISO SE DA A LA PRESENTE QUE la Comisión de Ciudad de Colusa y  Planificación llevará a cabo un...


CITY OF COLUSA NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that the City of Colusa and Planning Commission will hold public workshop on Wednesday, September...