Thursday, October 1, 2020

NEWSPAPER PUBLISHED WEEKLY ON WEDNESDAY - WEBSITE UPDATED THURSDAY

Home Opinions There’s an Alternative to the Imperial Presidency

There’s an Alternative to the Imperial Presidency

In his State of the Union speech to Congress last month, President Obama drew widespread attention for pledging to use his executive authority to advance his priorities. He insisted he intends to act with or without Congress, and listed well over a dozen actions he plans to take by executive order. “Wherever and whenever I can take steps without legislation to expand opportunity for more American families,” he said, “that’s what I’m going to do.”

Plenty of people were happy about this. The speech was applauded by pundits who have given up on Congress and believe the only way to move forward is by strengthening the presidency. Our political system, they say, is weighed down by too many interest groups, too many checks and balances, and too few avenues for circumventing a Congress that is both polarized and highly susceptible to the wishes of its donors. The present government is paralyzed, they believe. A stronger presidency would get Washington moving again.

As you’d expect, others are alarmed by this approach. The President, they say, is trampling on the constitutional separation of powers, grabbing powers for himself that were meant to be shared with Congress. They point out that the Constitution gives Congress a primary role in making policy.

The problem with this debate is that it’s missing a key part of the equation. Yes, our system needs a strong presidency. But it also needs a strong Congress. We are best off as a nation when the two consult, interact, and work together as powerful branches.

In truth, every president in recent memory has expanded the power of his office and been accused of a power grab. They’ve had plenty of motivation to do so. The modern world demands quick, decisive action. Americans tend to support presidents who act forcefully. Congress is complex, convoluted, and hard to work with; it is far easier for an administration to act on its own. Even members of Congress often defer to the President, counting on him to address issues they don’t want to tackle or can’t agree upon.

And presidents have wielded executive orders to great effect. Abraham Lincoln’s Emancipation Proclamation, FDR’s Works Progress Administration, John Kennedy’s Peace Corps, affirmative action under Kennedy, Lyndon Johnson and Richard Nixon, Ronald Reagan’s enshrining of cost-benefit analysis as the key to regulatory review — all came about through executive orders.

Yet there are limits to this approach, because in the end there is no substitute for legislation. Presidents cannot write a budget, raise the minimum wage, or reform entitlements by themselves. Because executive orders lack the permanence and force of law, they can be hard to implement and can be summarily cancelled by a later president. They are more subject to legal challenge than legislation. And most important, executive orders are a unilateral exercise of power and do not benefit from a process of consensus-building and consultation with voices independent of the President’s.

Consensus-building can’t happen in a vacuum, however. Without a strong Congress able to find its way effectively through the thickets of lawmaking, this President and his successors will surely continue to address the nation’s challenges on their own. The question is, how far down that road can we go before Congress becomes irrelevant, with too much power — and too much potential for the abuse of power — in presidential hands? Like our founding fathers, we should be skeptical of the concentration of power.

Politico recently detailed a spate of executive orders planned by this administration, which would affect everything from how power plants operate to how we commute to how the environment will be regulated. Taken together, they will “push deeply into everyday life” for Americans, the article noted.

Whether a president oversteps his authority with these and other executive orders is inevitably colored by whether you agree with the proposed order. But my point is different. It is that the march toward presidential unilateralism, whether the president is a Democrat or a Republican, dangerously undercuts our constitutional system. Before we give up on the separation of powers, let’s try strengthening Congress. This may not be the easy route, but if we don’t take it, representative democracy itself is in doubt.

 

Lee Hamilton is Director of the Center on Congress at Indiana University. He was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives for 34 years.

 

Submissions
Submissions
The Williams Pioneer Review has a small staff of one, covering all of Colusa County; but we’re proud to have the assistance of a large army of community contributors to extend our range and reach. This is one of those stories. If you have a story you would like to share, please email them to: news@colusacountynews.com or give us a call.

More News

Sex offender registry to see dramatic change in 2021

Two convicted child molesters were sentenced last week for failing to register as sex offenders, a consequence that could jeopardize their chances of getting...

Surviving the election: How to protect yourself from the stress of politics

We interrupt your latest binge of breaking political news, fear-provoking campaign commercials and angry posts from your favorite pundit to report that politics can...

Social Media and Kids: What Parents Can Do to Ensure Safe Use

The negative effects of social media have been much discussed as of late, thanks to the recently released documentary on Netflix, “The Social Dilemma.” The...

FBN – Amedee’s Flower & Gift

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT FILE NO. 2020-0000080 Date filed: September 28, 2020 The following persons are doing business as: AMEDEE’S FLOWER & GIFT Business Address: 734 E. Street, Williams,...

Quilters serve local needs, fire victims

Had it not been for a coronavirus pandemic, the Pacific Flyway Quilters would have held their annual Community Service Giveaway Night with a little...

Local Government

Colusa Unified to address online etiquette

Sharing yourself with others inside your personal space has been a challenge to students in COVID times. That is what some students said about distance...

City grants permit for cannabis expansion

Colusa’s first cannabis nursery is now looking to expand operations to include full marijana cultivation. The Colusa City Council voted 4-1, on Sept. 15, to...

Local governments spending CARES to boost IT infrastructure

In order to reduce physical interaction between individuals in the era of Covid-19, local governments are using CARES Act funding to invest in better...

Public & Legal Notices

FBN – Terra Organics; Aurora Seeds

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT FILE NO. 2020-0000075 Date filed: September 23 2020 The following persons are doing business as: TERRA ORGANICS and AURORA SEEDS Business Address: 311 N. BUTTE...

FBN – Maribel’s Janitorial Service

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT FILE NO. 2020-0000076 Date filed: September 24, 2020 The following persons are doing business as: MARIBEL’S JANITORIAL SERVICE Business Address: 203 5TH STREET, ARBUCKLE, CA...

FBN – Market Street Grill

FICTITIOUS BUSINESS NAME STATEMENT FILE NO. 2020-0000077 Date filed: September 25, 2020 The following persons are doing business as: MARKET STREET GRILL Business Address: 415 MARKET STREET, COLUSA, CA...

Notice Inviting Bids – Cortina Community Services District

CORTINA COMMUNITY SERVICES DISTRICT NOTICE INVITING BIDS Sealed bids received by the undersigned will be opened at the Arbuckle Golf Club, 5918 Hillgate Rd., Arbuckle,...

Notice of Petition of Administer Estate of Loyd Paul Locvich

NOTICE OF PETITION TO ADMINISTER ESTATE OF LOYD PAUL LOCVICH Case Number PR8246 To all heirs, beneficiaries, creditors, contingent creditors, and persons who may otherwise be interested...